Microsoft launched seven MAI models at Ignite on November 17. The one aimed at my bill is MAI Code 2, now in GitHub Copilot. The headline:
— Microsoft AIMAI Code 2 gives you 98% of the performance of GPT-6.1 Sol at 40% of the cost, and 96% of Claude Opus 5.5’s performance at just 5% of the cost.
Then the footnote: “MAI Code 2 cost is shown at its 50% promotional price.” The benchmarks “were run on MSBench (Microsoft’s internal eval platform) with the GitHub Copilot CLI without subagents.” No independent coding score exists yet.
The top comment on r/ClaudeAI, with 519 points, put it best: “The other 4% is a major outage.” The next day, GitHub’s status page reported “Degraded Availability for MAI Code 2 Flash in Copilot”.
The Price Behind the 5%
| Per million tokens | Input | Output |
|---|---|---|
| MAI Code 2, promo to May 17 2027 | $0.50 | $2.50 |
| MAI Code 2, list | $1 | $5 |
| Claude Opus 5.5 | $4 | $20 |
- Per token, MAI Code 2 is 12.5% of Opus now and 25% after the promo.
- The 5% is per benchmark task: $0.31 against $6.31 on Microsoft’s average. Opus spends more tokens per task.
- Microsoft’s own average still puts Opus ahead: 65.3% against 63.2%. Opus wins the two harder benchmarks, SWE Atlas and FrontierCode.
None of this is hidden. Microsoft printed every caveat on the launch page. The headline just leaves them out.
The Same Six Changes
I bought Copilot Pro ($10 a month) and ran MAI Code 2 on the bench from the Carbon, Fable 5.2 and Sonnet 5.5 posts: six merged changes from a production monorepo, each replayed on a clean snapshot, graded by the tests the original fix shipped with. Copilot CLI, medium effort, 20 runs.
| 20 runs each | MAI Code 2 | Opus 5.5 | Sonnet 5.5 | GPT-6.1 Sol |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Runs that passed every test | 8 | 13 | 11 | 11 |
| Runs that broke a test that passed before | 5 | 0 | 0 | 5 |
| New tests fixed | 92% | 92% | 88% | 94% |
| Total cost | $5.29 promo, $10.58 list | $38.45 | $11.76 | $6.73 |
- It fixes the new tests. 92%, the same as Opus. The gap is what it breaks on the way.
- Change A broke the same test three times. Every run made all 24 new tests pass. Three of four also broke one old test about manifested parcels.
- Change C beat it, like every model. 10 of 27 new tests across three runs. Opus fixed 11, Sonnet 9.
- Changes E and F were perfect. 6 clean runs of 6, at about $0.26 a run.
- Cost: about 14% of Opus at the promo price, 28% at list. Not 5%, but still a big cut.
- At list price it matches Sonnet’s bill. Sonnet 5.5 did 11 clean runs, broke nothing, and cost $11.76.
Copilot CLI is the harness Microsoft used for its own numbers, so this is MAI Code 2 at home. One difference: Copilot CLI started its own helper agents in four runs, including one GPT-6 Luna call that cost $0.0001. Microsoft ran without subagents. I left the defaults on.
What the Crowd Found
The firsthand reports split about evenly. The bad ones have more detail. cFullerene on r/ClaudeAI:
— cFullerene, r/ClaudeAIIt wrote ‘useing’ (instead of ‘using’) and completely borked a ton of models in our project. It renamed stuff for no apparent reason… It went well beyond the scope of what I asked to modify hundreds of files with garbage.
The good ones talk about cost. KariKariKrigsmann ran a review on a 30,000-line C# codebase. MAI Code 2 found 8 issues for 19 AI credits. Sonnet 5.5 found 5 for 136.
Mustafa Suleyman’s pitch is that most work does not need a frontier model:
— Mustafa SuleymanBecause when the same model is built to also push the frontier of science, you pay for that capability on every task, even for a routine bug fix.
My bench agrees with half of that. On the routine changes, MAI Code 2 was perfect and cheap. On the rest, it broke things.
What MAI Code 2 Doesn’t Solve
- Regressions. Five broken runs of 20. That is GPT-6.1 Sol’s record, and Sol costs less than MAI Code 2 at list.
- Hard changes. Microsoft says the models are “explicitly not yet tuned for harder problems”. It did not do better on Change C than anyone else.
- Speed. 367 seconds per run on average. One user on X measured 47 tokens per second in Copilot.
- The promo clock. On May 18 2027 every number in the cost row doubles.
- Sample size. Six changes from one codebase. Another codebase could rank these models differently.
Lessons
- Read the footnote first. “96% at 5%” became 8 clean runs of 20 at 14%.
- A cheap model needs a check behind it. MAI Code 2 fixes what you ask and breaks what you did not. Run the old tests, or put a second model on review.
- Send it the routine work. On small, well-defined fixes it was perfect at a quarter of a dollar.
- Run your own tasks before May. That is the cheapest MAI Code 2 will be.



